미르잘랄파이줄라예프
(Mirjalol Fayzullaev)
1iD
프리모바홀리다
(Primova Holida)
2iD
오염덕
(Ryumduck Oh)
†iD
-
(Dept. of ITㆍEnergy Convergence, Korea National University of Transportation, Korea
E-mail : fayzullaevmirjalol@ut.ac.kr)
-
(Dept. of Information Technologies, Samarkand Branch of Tashkent University of Information
Technologies, Samarkand 140100,Uzbekistan
E-mail : primova@samtuit.uz)
Copyright © The Korea Institute for Structural Maintenance and Inspection
Key words
PTV Vissim, Traffic flow, Intersection, Traffic light, Lane change heuristic model, MOBIL model
1. Introduction
Traffic safety and the efficiency of traffic and passenger flow management are evaluated
by the reliability and error tolerance of the software and technical means of the
traffic management system. Therefore, it is important to use modern technologies of
communication and management in the development of traffic management and traffic
management systems. The development of such systems is a current demand and urgent
issue.
Today, the organization of traffic in big cities, especially in the central parts
of the city, is one of the big and pending issues. This problem can be explained by
the fact that it has arisen due to the increase in the level of motorization. The
partially or completely unorganized movement of vehicles on the roads not only affects
traffic safety but also sharply reduces the capacity of the street network.
Partial or complete disruption of the movement of vehicles on the roads not only endangers
traffic safety but also drastically reduces the capacity of the street network. The
decision to change the construction of roads, that is, the construction of bridges,
and tunnels with a sharp improvement in traffic in cities, is a long-term one, but
it requires quite large financial and time costs. This problem can be solved without
financial and time costs by using a computerized automatic traffic control system
on the city road network.
Traffic safety, efficiency of traffic control and passenger flow is assessed by the
reliability and fault tolerance of software and hardware means of the traffic control
system. Therefore, it is important to use modern communication and control technologies
when developing a traffic management and traffic management system. The development
of such systems is an urgent need and an urgent task [1,2].
Traffic control algorithms based on traffic flow models are widely used in the transport
network of cities. The requirements for the accuracy and complexity of the models
are extremely high. Suffice it to say that at the simplest intersection, there can
be 12 directions of movement of vehicles. For a section of the road network consisting
of 10 such intersections, we are talking about 120 routes, and if the volume of traffic
on each of these routes constantly changes in time and space, it is necessary to minimize
delays.
Initially, the theory of traffic flows was an applied science that solved particular
problems of transport (for example, the study and justification of the passability
of roads and their intersections) and was based mainly on empirical data. In the early
1950s, the theory of traffic flows took shape and became an independent scientific
direction. The ideas of statistics, hydrodynamics, etc. began to be used to describe
traffic flows. This period is characterized by the rapid development of scientific
thinking and the formation of the main directions of research [1].
M.Lighthill, G.B.Whitham, and P.Richards, in 1955 proposed the first macroscopic model
and model (LWR-model), in which the traffic flow was considered from the point of
view of continuum mechanics. Further development of the transport system of Russia,
expansion of the road network and increase in connectivity, increasing the role of
multimodal transportation, the introduction of intelligent transport systems, and
the problem of congestion of the main transport corridors necessitated the use of
transport models [3,4].
Prevention of traffic jams at traffic lights is one of the most pressing problems
today. Every year the number of cars increases, which complicates the solution of
this problem. As such traffic jams increase, the number of collisions and injuries
to pedestrians also increase year by year, according to statistics. To ensure the
safety and continuity of traffic around the world, traffic controllers use FLIR's
intelligent technologies to improve traffic flows and transport systems on the roads.
In the field of traffic management, FLIR's detection and control solutions are successfully
helping to manage traffic and ensure safety. FLIR software is also very useful for
protecting the environment, detecting incidents on highways and tunnels, collecting
traffic data, and public transport safety. The FLIR traffic sensor enables traffic
cops to control traffic lights at intersections and efficiently manage city traffic.
They also help optimize the safety of pedestrians, cyclists, and heavy traffic [3]. In addition to preventing accidents, thermal imaging allows the timely detection
of fires in vehicles and helps dispatchers monitor the presence of passengers.
2. Methods of modelling transport flows
When designing any traffic interchange (intersections of city highways at one or different
levels), the designer always has questions, for example, what kind of traffic mode
the selected geometry creates at the designed intersection. Also, in other cases,
each project for the reconstruction or construction of a new road junction requires
approval in state programs.
However, when intersections of different levels and other complex nodes begin to appear
in the road network of cities, our researchers set themselves the goal of obtaining
reliable information about the structure of future road transport and the features
of its operation. This is how the design stage or pre-project proposals (concepts)
began to develop, as well as the section "Theory of traffic flows" and its mathematical
model.
Our domestic scientists faced this problem much later than their foreign counterparts.
In this regard, the models of the theory of traffic flows created by domestic researchers
are not considered in this paper.
At the moment, foreign scientists are faced with the opposite situation. Donald Drew
in his book "Theory of traffic flow and Control" analyzed the problem of realizing
the problem faced by many young researchers who began work in the field of "Theory
of traffic flow". In this case, the formulas are a collection of many types of models,
ranging from a single formula to entire arrays that can only be processed by a computer.
However, at the moment, the theory of traffic flow has long been a necessary tool
in the field of traffic flow modelling, and there is no point in "reinventing the
wheel" here. Only available resources should be properly used. This section discusses
some well-known approaches to traffic flow modelling.
2.1 PTV Vision model in the Vissim software package
The Vissim is a simulation model for realistically simulating urban and intercity
transportation, including pedestrian traffic, that is microscopic, time-stepping,
and behavior-based. This simulation system consists of two separate programs that
interact with each other through an interface where the measurement data of the detectors
and information about the state of the control systems are exchanged.
Traffic flow is simulated based on various parameters, such as lane allocation, vehicle
composition, signal management, and the detection of private and public vehicles.
The result of the simulation is to animate traffic in graphical form in real time,
and then display all kinds of traffic and technical parameters, such as the distribution
of travel time and waiting time, differentiated by user groups (Fig 1).
Fig. 1. Main window of PTV Vissim software package
The traffic flow model includes a next-vehicle model and a lane change model to represent
single-lane traffic in a column behind the vehicle ahead. Traffic control logic is
modeled with external lighting control software [9]. The logic control program requests the parameters of the sensors in the period from
1 second to 1/10 of a second (depending on the installation and type of traffic light).
Based on the obtained values and time intervals, the program determines the state
of all control systems for the next simulation stage and includes them in the traffic
flow simulation.
2.2 Lane change heuristic model
Wei H. proposed a heuristic framework for the distribution of city streets based on
video images of the behavior of the lane change model rule. In addition to mandatory,
a new type of mandatory lane change (MLC) and voluntary lane change (DLC) have been
introduced. The driver makes a turning maneuver not at a certain intersection, but
only when he has such an intention [11].
The lane change is described according to the maneuver and position of the vehicle
in question [10]. There are three types of this movement: T_Ld (when the car approaches the target
line); T_Lg (car delay on the target line); H_T (vehicle movement in the priority
lane) with the corresponding thresholds obtained based on the study of external information.
If all three movements exceed the specified limits, a lane change is accepted after
a certain time interval determined by the type of lane change and the speed of movement.
It should be noted that this model does not take into account the reasons for changing
lanes, as well as the interaction and communication between vehicles.
2.3 MOBIL model
Like other models, the MOBIL model addresses the issue of lane changes by considering
the advantages (incentives) of driving as well as extra guidelines for road safety.
The peculiarity of the lane change is that it depends on the decision-making behavior
and the flow of the moving vehicle (Fig 2).
Fig. 2. Diagram of the interaction of vehicles when changing lanes
The criterion of the MOBIL model includes a direct consideration of the impact of
nearby vehicles. Indicates the benefit (usefulness) of changing lanes directly to
the driver. Determines the degree of influence of neighboring vehicles on the driver's
decision to change lanes.
Here $a_{c}$ represents the new acceleration c of the car after the expected one,
the $p(a_{n}+ a_{0}-\check{a}_{0})$ weighting factor p represents the total gain (or
total loss for negative values) from lane change for adjacent vehicles. The threshold
value on the right-hand side of the formula simulates some inertia in decision-making,
and it prevents the line from changing.
We can clearly see traffic jams and traffic inconveniences in every city center of
Samarkand. In this article, the intersection of Ibn Sina and Dahbed streets of the
city of Samarkand was chosen as the object of study (Fig 3).
Fig. 3. Geographical location of the selected object
Table 1 The results of the study of movement along thestreets of Ibn Sina and Dahbed
The name of the street
|
The number of parking spaces for cars along the street
|
Number of parking lots by location
|
Carriage way lanes
|
45°-60°
|
90°
|
0°
|
Ibn Sino Street
|
Right
|
12
|
6
|
5
|
5
|
3
|
Left
|
11
|
7
|
|
5
|
3
|
Dahbed street
|
Right
|
12
|
11
|
|
6
|
2
|
Left
|
6
|
9
|
|
1
|
2
|
This area is an object that is often visited by the population of Samarkand. The
population near the intersection of Ibn Sina and Dahbed streets is densely populated.
Therefore, on the roads of Ibn Sina and Dahbed streets, especially during the beginning
and end of classes. during the "rush hour" there are congestion and inconvenience
for drivers and pedestrians, unfortunately, there are many traffic accidents.
Table 2 Traffic flow of the intersection Ibn Sino and Dahbed
Time
|
Week days
|
Mon.
|
Tue.
|
Wed.
|
Thu.
|
Fri.
|
Sat.
|
Sun.
|
8:09
|
1758
|
1865
|
1854
|
1875
|
1885
|
1875
|
1100
|
9:10
|
2122
|
2100
|
2210
|
2142
|
2145
|
2089
|
1100
|
10:11
|
1850
|
1758
|
1897
|
1789
|
1689
|
1850
|
1152
|
11:12
|
1589
|
1576
|
1587
|
1489
|
1489
|
1468
|
1120
|
12:13
|
1895
|
1945
|
1977
|
1885
|
1884
|
1852
|
1122
|
13:14
|
1758
|
1688
|
1710
|
1565
|
1548
|
1573
|
1200
|
14:15
|
1885
|
1458
|
1876
|
1763
|
1695
|
1785
|
1130
|
15:16
|
1869
|
1755
|
1785
|
1689
|
1452
|
1489
|
1100
|
16:17
|
1899
|
1978
|
1888
|
1778
|
1852
|
1881
|
1103
|
17:18
|
1968
|
1982
|
1954
|
1895
|
1786
|
1785
|
1201
|
18:19
|
1789
|
1796
|
1775
|
1785
|
1897
|
1752
|
1113
|
19:20
|
1200
|
1125
|
1120
|
1129
|
1100
|
1052
|
850
|
20:21
|
487
|
428
|
389
|
387
|
345
|
385
|
203
|
21:22
|
221
|
224
|
241
|
224
|
210
|
205
|
127
|
In order to ensure traffic safety, all elements affecting the placement of cars in
street conditions and safe traffic were analyzed. Today, car parking along the road
has a major impact.
For this reason, with the help of the PTV VISSIM program, a study, and analysis were
carried out on whether the parking capacity around objects of social and economic
importance is at the required level and how much it affects the flow of cars parked
from the side of the street adjacent to it. In order to improve the quality of service
at the parking lot, it became necessary to increase the capacity of parking lots around
urban socio-economic facilities.
Fig. 4. Graph of traffic flows at the Ibn Sina and Dahbed junction
To solve these problems, we can create a traffic model using the PTV Vissim program
(Fig 4). To determine the current state of the object of study designated by us, a 1-hour
video of the traffic flow was recorded during the daytime rush hour, and by analytically
counting the number of cars that passed through the intersection, a computer model
was created, and analyzed. In it, hourly values were calculated for one daytime and
evening rush hour as of February 4, 2021 (Fig 5) [6].
Fig. 5. Computer model created in the PVT vissim program
In practice, speed or travel time is an important indicator of the quality of transport
service in determining the amount of traffic flow and street capacity. At intersections,
the main measure is not the speed of vehicles, but their delay. It determines the
level of maintenance of city streets and is an important performance indicator.
When evaluating the quality of a controlled intersection, it is difficult to describe
some performance indicators. There are several measures related to capacity analysis
and modelling, all of which depend on many aspects of the experience of a pedestrian
or driver crossing a signalized intersection. The most common metrics are average
vehicle delay, average travel length, and number of vehicle stops.
These three metrics are the most commonly used performance metrics at signalized intersections
because they are directly perceived by the driver. Many studied sources have shown
that the throughput of intersections with traffic lights in cities ranges from 1400
to 1800 cars per hour [9]. The level of service (LOS) is also assessed when evaluating signalized intersections
(Table 3).
Table 3 Level of Service (LOS)
LOS
|
Sec/аutо
|
A
|
≤ 10
|
B
|
> 10 – 20
|
C
|
> 20 – 35
|
D
|
> 35 – 55
|
E
|
> 55 – 80
|
F
|
> 80
|
Urban street conditions can vary greatly, and parking spaces, transit buses, road
widths, surrounding connecting intersections, and other factors can significantly
affect observed volumes [12]. Based on the results of a computer model created for specific conditions, it is
possible to effectively manage traffic lights with different phases, check the correct
organization of traffic and choose an alternative option that suits the conditions.
3. The results obtained
In this study, analyzing the results of the current situation, several theoretical
methods of reducing the delay time and optimizing the time parameters of the traffic
lights were considered to increase the throughput of the intersection. In the PTV
Vissim program, the following results were achieved by optimizing the time parameters
of traffic lights.Initially, the traffic light phases are optimized with the time
parameters of the current traffic light state through the “Green Matrix” phase type
of the PTV Vissim program (Fig 6).
Fig. 6. Entering phases into the “Intergreen Matrix”
Fig. 6. Entering phases into the “Intergreen Matrix”
Fig. 7. 2D view of Ibn Sino and Dakhbed streets of Samarkand in the PTV VISSIM program
Table 4 The current state of the intersection "Ibn Sino and Dahbed" according to 7
indicators
Indicators
|
Current status
|
Level of service (LOS)
|
LOS F
|
Average queue length (m)
|
230
|
Number of vehicles
|
4328
|
Average delay time (auto/sec)
|
15,9
|
Harmful gases CO (grams)
|
13808
|
NOx (grams)
|
2686
|
Fuel consumption
|
197,5
|
Having received the indicators in the current state, we will receive the results from
the program even in the absence of roadside parking spaces and compare them with the
results obtained from the current state. Below is a diagram constructed in the program
without accommodation (Fig 7), and the results obtained in the case without accommodation (표 4).
Analyzing the obtained results, we see that the road maintenance level in the current
state is equal to LOS F, and without calculations, this indicator will improve to
the LOS B level. When we get the practical results of 1 hour in the "rush hour" of
this area, in the current state with street parking and no parking as a test, the
average queue length, the number of cars, the average delay time, the program shows
harmful gases, fuel consumption. The difference between such indicators was taken
into account. For example, the difference in traffic, that is, the average length
of the queue, was 128 meters in both cases.
One of the most urgent problems in cities today is transport. This indicator shows
how traffic and parking problems are related to each other. To avoid traffic jams,
it is necessary to use the capacity of the road as much as possible. According to
the results obtained in the case of parking and no parking, the shoulder can carry
2080 more cars than under current conditions. A comparison of the average delay time
in the two cases showed a difference of almost 15 minutes.
At the same time, as a result of standing vehicles on the road, the emission of harmful
gases into the atmosphere has a great negative impact on the environment. As a result
of studies conducted in this area, it was noticed that in this area 13808 COx (grams)
of harmful gases were emitted in one hour under current conditions, and 3878 COx (grams)
in non-residential conditions.
Another important aspect of the transportation industry is fuel consumption. Of course,
traffic jams occur due to placement, and as a result, fuel is wasted. According to
the above results, 142 liters of fuel were used in the non-residential state compared
to the residential state in the study area. To solve these problems, it would be advisable
to turn residences in the area of Ibn Sina and Dahbed streets into multi-story parking
lots operating in the "smart residence" system, provide students with the opportunity
to use these residences, and also establish a fee for the use of residential premises.
Fig. 8. Time parameters on the phase section of a traffic light (optimized case)
After simulating the traffic situation with the PTV vissim software, the current throughput
of the intersection increased from 4,328 to 4,368 vehicles per hour during peak hours.
The maximum received queue length was reduced from 115 m to 80 m, and the average
vehicle delay was reduced from 42.49 s/h to 22.79 s/h. Level of Service (LOS) increased
from D to C as determined by program outcome.
4. Discussion
Analyzing the results we got in the PTV Vissim software, we can see that the throughput
level, traffic jam length, and average delay time changed when we optimized the intersection
in the single-phase section. Another convenience of the computer model is that we
can visualize the split model (Fig 4~Fig 8).
Economic and environmental benefits of conducting this kind of research:
· save fuel that is consumed at the idle speed of the engine due to traffic jams at
intersections
· a sharp decrease in the number of harmful substances that can be emitted into the
atmosphere due to fuel economy under given conditions
· saving time spent by road users on the movement of the driver, passenger, or pedestrian
5. Conclusion
The connection between the problem of intersections with traffic and traffic, which
has become the most urgent problem for developed and developing countries, has been
studied. According to the above analysis, the fact that vehicles parked along the
street have a significant impact on road safety requires research in this regard.
In the studies conducted by scientists in Uzbekistan, the use of intelligent transport
systems in the design of the organization of transport problems and ways to eliminate
them, as well as improving the efficiency of intersections and the effective organization
of their work, are not given enough. It is necessary to study foreign experience and
solve the issue of implementation on the example of the region on a scientific basis.
Currently, the results collected based on periodic studies are accepted as the main
sources for planning activities for the organization of traffic and the construction
of road structures in large cities. Old methods are used to determine speed, flow
composition, and speed characteristics on highways.
For example, estimated traffic load data for the road networks in Tashkent and Samarkand
were derived from information obtained from measurements taken at more than 50 reference
points over a period of several days, up to a maximum of one month. It was proposed
to create a complex of intelligent transport systems (ITS) to solve the above problems
with a high degree of accuracy and to have a reliable database.
Acknowledgements
This work was supported by the National Research Foundation of Korea (NRF) grant funded
by the Korean government (MSIT) (2020R1A2C1101867)
References
A. A. Vlasov, “Теория транспортных потоков,” Теория транспортных потоков: монография,
Пенза: ПГУАС, pp. 124, 2014.
Marija Burinskienė, Modesta Gusarovienė, Kristina Gabrulevičiūtė-Skebienė, “The impact
of public transport lanes on the operating speed of buses,” Environmental Engineering
2014, pp. 1–10, 2014.
X.A. Primova, Q. Gaybulov, O. R. Yalgashev, “Algorithm for constructing a model for
the choice of building materials for the construction,” in Proc. Blockchain, Computing
and Security (ICABCS 2023), pp. 1–5, 2023.
João Miguel, Gomes Rodrigues, Valente Neves, “The impacts of bus lanes on urban traffic
environment,” FEUP, pp. 1–10, 2006.
A. A. Muhitdinov, Q. R. Qutlimuratov, B. R. Turatov, Abduraxmonov R.A., “PTV Vissim
dasturiy kompleks yordamida boshqariladigan chorrahadagi transport vositalarining
tirbandligi va kechikishini hisoblash,” pp. 1–10, .
X. A. Primova, S. S. Mirzaraxmedov, “Transport oqimini PTV VISSIM paketi yordamida
modellashtirish,” Молодой специалист Young specialist Жас маман Yosh mutaxassis, pp.
47–54, August 2022. Available at: https://www.mspes.kz/
M. Fellendorf, P. Vortisch, “Validation of the microscopic traffic flow model VISSIM
in different real-world situations,” Transportation Research Board, pp. 1–10, 2001.
Transportation Research Board, “Highway Capacity Manual,” Transportation Research
Board of the National Academies, pp. 1–10, 2010.
Т. Мэтсон, “Организация движения,” Научно-техническое издательство Министерства автомобильного
транспорта и автомобильных дорог RSFSR, pp. 1–10, Москва, 1960.
H. Wei, E. Meyer, J. Lee, & C. Feng, “Characterizing and modeling observed lane-changing
behavior: Lane-vehicle-based microscopic simulation on urban street network,” Transportation
Research Record, pp. 1–10, 2000.https://doi.org/10.3141/1710-12
Y. Wu, L. Zhang, R. Lou, X. Li, “Recognition of lane-changing maneuvers for vehicle
driving safety,” Electronics, pp. 1456, 2023.https://doi.org/10.3390/electronics12061456
H. Primova, Q. Gaybulov, I. Isroilov, “Selection of Building Material Using the Decision-Making
System,” in Proc. 2021 International Conference on Information Science and Communications
Technologies (ICISCT), Uzbekistan, pp. 1–3, 2021.https://doi.org/10.1109/ICISCT52966.2021.9670051
저자소개
미르잘랄 파이줄라예프(Mirjalol Fayzullaev)
Mirjalol Fayzullaev received his B.S. and M.S. degrees in Computer Engineering from
the Tashkent University of Information Technologies, Uzbekistan, in 2019. From 2019
to 2023, he served as a Research Assistant in the Department of Information Technologies
at the Tashkent University of Information Technologies. His research interests include
Machine Learning, Artificial Intelligence, Big Data, IoT, Deep Learning algorithms,
and real-time monitoring systems.
Primova Holida is a Professor in the Department of Information Technologies at the
Samarkand branch of the Tashkent University of Information Technologies. Her disciplines
include Architectural Engineering, Automotive Engineering, and Computer Engineering.
Her skills and expertise encompass Fuzzy Logic, Fuzzy Set Theory, Soft Computing,
Fuzzy Theory, Fuzzy Mathematics, Fuzzy Clustering, Genetic Programming, Intelligent
Computing, and Nonlinear Regression.
Ryumduck Oh is a Professor in the department of Software at Korea National University
of Transportation. He received the Ph.D. degree in Computer Science at Hongik University
Seoul, Korea, in 1993. He received the B.S. and M.S. degrees in Computer Science from
Hongik University in 1986 and 1988, respectively. His research interest includes the
big data analysis and the IoT platform on railway environment.